调查大陆访问套 CF 网速

[serafin]

在这个 https://www.v2ex.com/t/905693 帖子中，经提醒发现 http 与 https 速度差异巨大，部分地区 https 被 QoS 非常严重，甚至只有 0.x Mbps ，而 http 却可以跑到 60+ Mbps. 麻烦大家用 http 和 https 分别测试。

http://cn-http.speed.ga

https://cn-https.speed.ga

[ljhrot]

HTTPS:
Download0.09Mbps Upload4.71Mbps Ping385.60ms Jitter269.52ms

HTTP:
Download9.83Mbps Upload41.52Mbps Ping375.70ms Jitter15.94ms

中国移动 IPv6 深圳

[XIU2]

因为目前主要针对的是 Cloudflare 的 443 端口，毕竟绝大部分流量都是 HTTPS 协议 + 443 端口。

[Rasphino]

HTTP：
Download: 3.78Mbps
Upload: 27.09Mbps
Ping: 646.00ms
Jitter: 358.80ms

HTTPS:
Download: 15.94Mbps
Upload: 30.65Mbps
Ping: 417.00ms
Jitter: 194.58ms

福建福州移动

[wuvvu]

佛山顺德电信 ipv4
https Download 1.82Mbps Upload 15.75Mbps Ping 327.30ms Jitter 8.65ms
http Download 66.56Mbps Upload 15.96Mbps Ping 331.40ms Jitter 7.26ms

[Oct31Dec25]

HTTP:
Download 70.12Mbps
Upload 24.90Mbps
Ping 346.90ms
Jitter 10.38ms

HTTPS:
Download 0.10Mbps
Upload 9.99Mbps
Ping 386.70ms
Jitter 608.08ms

广东东莞移动

[Kiriya]

Access denied
Error code 1020
You do not have access to cn-http.speed.ga.

The site owner may have set restrictions that prevent you from accessing the site

[xfxz]

HTTP:
Download130.35Mbps Upload40.97Mbps Ping320.90ms Jitter10.14ms

HTTPS：
Download0.34Mbps Upload55.12Mbps Ping304.20ms Jitter289.41ms

江苏电信

[Thanch]

HTTP：
Download51.24Mbps Upload32.76Mbps Ping399.50ms Jitter2.06ms

HTTPS:
Download3.08Mbps Upload32.38Mbps Ping418.20ms Jitter891.50ms

成都移动家宽 1000M

[myd]

Access denied

[spicy777]

深圳电信 ipv4

[spicy777]

HTTP：
Download91.98Mbps Upload22.38Mbps Ping330.40ms Jitter102.64ms

HTTPS:
Download2.24Mbps Upload33.96Mbps Ping330.90ms Jitter8.46ms

[serafin]

@Kiriya
@myd
需要大陆 ip

[baobao1270]

补充三个单点样本，可能是我的问题，我目前套 cf 的网站:
福州电信:SNI 阻断
南宁:移动 SNI 阻断，电信通

[ChineseTeacher]

HTTP 和 HTTPS 速度差异巨大，lz 确定不是 HTTP 被缓存了吗？

[ChineseTeacher]

指被运营商劫持并缓存

[serafin]

@ChineseTeacher 我无法证明没有被运营商劫持，但是测速流量后台确实有记录到。

[nothing2]

http
Download65.00Mbps Upload12.60Mbps
Ping504.00ms Jitter3.56

https
Download80.60Mbps Upload2.27Mbps
Ping505.00ms Jitter3.85

成都移动

[clg561696]

HTTP Download37.00Mbps Upload23.11Mbps
Ping343.70ms Jitter304.53ms
HTTPS Download46.25Mbps Upload18.01Mbps
Ping336.20ms Jitter37.22ms
陕西电信

[anonydmer]

Http：
Download 151.20Mbps Upload 23.47Mbps Ping 315.50ms Jitter 6.23ms

Https：
Download 11.13Mbps Upload 37.92Mbps Ping 385.10ms Jitter 11.81ms

[datou]

http

Download175.13Mbps Upload114.29Mbps Ping339.30ms Jitter16.82ms

https

Download95.47Mbps Upload133.24Mbps Ping323.00ms Jitter9.33ms

湖北电信 ipv4

[ragnaroks]

武汉电信

http：145.91 、12.52
https：156.66 、19.23

[sarices]

Access denied
Error code 1020
You do not have access to cn-http.speed.ga.

The site owner may have set restrictions that prevent you from accessing the site.

[JamesLewisLiu]

广州电信 1000M

HTTP Download117.42Mbps Upload29.40Mbps Ping329.10ms Jitter3.09ms
HTTPS Download12.72Mbps Upload48.53Mbps Ping331.00ms Jitter2.65ms

[levenwindy]

早上 10 点
广东联通
Download103.77Mbps Upload1.44Mbps
晚上下行只有 1M 不到，http 打不开

广东电信
http
Download170.51Mbps Upload29.27Mbps
Https
download154.96mbps upload26.92mbps

[agood]

湖北联通
http
Download29.41Mbps Upload20.94Mbps Ping370.00ms Jitter13.44ms
https
Download8.30Mbps Upload5.01Mbps Ping416.20ms Jitter23.81ms

[Jimmyisme]

深圳电信
http
Download178.59Mbps Upload108.36Mbps Ping333.20ms Jitter2.98ms
https
Download24.95Mbps Upload88.88Mbps Ping330.10ms Jitter7.15ms

[mhycy]

104.21.86.250
解析出来的这个 IP 无法访问

[ikichen]

上海电信
http
Download35.72Mbps Upload10.16Mbps Ping296.50ms Jitter3.05ms
https
Download10.31Mbps Upload3.71Mbps Ping339.40ms Jitter74.10ms

[imzcc]

北京电信 50M
http
Download38.17Mbps Upload40.65Mbps Ping327.40ms Jitter5.61ms

https
Download2.56Mbps Upload21.27Mbps Ping328.50ms Jitter16.88ms

[RRyo]

https://17ce.com/
多地测试用这种平台啊

[linhu66]

上海电信-CN2

HTTP
Download125.68Mbps Upload162.68Mbps Ping431.10ms Jitter6.04ms
IP Address: 58.32.24.** - China Telecom (Group) - CN,Shanghai,Shanghai
HTTPS
Download42.17Mbps Upload122.18Mbps Ping435.20ms Jitter2.13ms
IP Address: 58.32.24.** - China Telecom (Group) - CN,Shanghai,Shanghai

[linhu66]

@ikichen 同样是上海电信我比你快多了

[Kenmin]

江苏电信
HTTP Download 46.04Mbps Upload 72.41Mbps Ping 345.50ms Jitter 8.87ms
HTTPS Download 7.49Mbps Upload 11.82Mbps Ping 372.80ms Jitter 6.46ms

[ChineseTeacher]

@serafin #16 测速传输的内容是随机的吗？

[hahiru]

http: Download 87.96 Mbps Upload 25.73 Mbps Ping 397.00 ms Jitter 6.08 ms
https: Download 0.76 Mbps Upload 12.97 Mbps Ping 333.00 ms Jitter 30.97 ms
浙江电信

[cxsz]

http: Download47.38Mbps Upload51.93Mbps Ping390.60ms Jitter127.90ms
https: Download0.57Mbps Upload3.71Mbps Ping394.60ms Jitter53.14ms
北京联通

[r03r03]

http: Access denied Error code 1020 You do not have access to cn-http.speed.ga.
https: Download11.61Mbps Upload4.17Mbps Ping355.50ms Jitter12.50ms

[DonnyChao]

Download 45.90Mbps Upload 40.97Mbps Ping 343.80ms Jitter 79.04ms

IP Address: CHINANET-BACKBONE - CN,Hunan,Changsha 湖南长沙

[serafin]

@ChineseTeacher 测速传输的内容是随机的吗？用 openssl_random_pseudo_bytes 生成伪随机字节串

[systemcall]

都很慢了，可能是已经被 qos 了

[systemcall]

ipv6 我这边也很慢了，但是 jitter 好很多
希望再做一下分类，给个纯 v4 和纯 v6 的

[huangsijun17]

http:
Download126.06Mbps Upload29.22Mbps Ping309.90ms Jitter3.22ms
IP Address: 240e:38b:89d2:e600:8deb:cc94:a3d8:e02d - China Telecom (Group) - CN,Beijing,Chaowai

https:
Download111.17Mbps Upload21.10Mbps Ping303.90ms Jitter6.01ms
IP Address: 240e:38b:89d2:e600:8deb:cc94:a3d8:e02d - China Telecom (Group) - CN,Beijing,Chaowai

我是不是还得把 IPv6 关了？
PS：地址是临时地址。

[winzkh]

广东河源移动 IP Address: 223.74.59.185 - China Mobile Communications Group Co., Ltd. - CN,Guangdong,Guangzhou
http:
Download 109.33Mbps
Upload 33.07Mbps
Ping 359.60ms
Jitter 46.02ms

https:
Download 0.16Mbps
Upload 41.92Mbps
Ping 341.20ms
Jitter 528.80ms

[joshuaily]

https

Download109.37Mbps
Upload81.42Mbps
Ping450.20ms J
itter4.50m

http

Download125.39Mbps
Upload68.59Mbps
Ping453.50ms
Jitter5.39ms

[kleos]

楼主是不是按照 as 号过滤访问的 一直 1020

[strp]

2023/01/08 非晚高峰
HTTPS Download 99.46Mbps Upload 0.13Mbps Ping 395.40ms Jitter 7.72ms
HTTP Download 123.25Mbps Upload 61.06Mbps Ping 330.70ms Jitter 8.53ms
IP Address: CHINANET-BACKBONE - CN,Guangdong,Shenzhen

[serafin]

@kleos CF 防火墙过滤国家

[loukky]

把你的随机加密关了呀,http 一直跳转到 https 然后 1020

[serafin]

@loukky 无痕模式试试看，不行换个浏览器看看

[xzcfz123]

2023/1/9 http 可以打开 https 打不开
下面是 http 的数据
Download 155.02 Mbps
Upload 13.77 Mbps
Ping 382.00 ms
Jitter 4.57 ms

[xzcfz123]

地区是江苏移动

[jyeric]

HTTP
Download70.13Mbps Upload79.99Mbps Ping339.60ms Jitter44.66ms
HTTPS Access denied 1020

[jyeric]

@jyeric I got an error when visiting cn-https.speed.ga/.

Error code: 1020
Ray ID: 78736ba8dc42f9f9
Country: CN
Data center: sjc07
IP:
Timestamp: 2023-01-10 06:40:19 UTC

[serafin]

@jyeric 谢谢提供的 Ray ID ，是我设置错误导致的。我关闭了 SSL/TLS 导致 CF 强行把 https://cn-https.speed.ga 改为 http ，我的防火墙不允许用 http 访问 cn-https 。

[jyeric]

http(ipv6)
Download140.10Mbps Upload115.38Mbps Ping333.10ms Jitter27.67ms
https(ipv4)
Download68.20Mbps Upload66.71Mbps Ping339.20ms Jitter27.13ms